search marketing

The Impact Online Reviews Have on Search Rankings

Written by Paul Steinbrueck

Get the latest Christian Web Trends Insights

By submitting this form, I give OurChurch.Com permission to send me communication by email.

Earlier this week, we kicked off Online Reviews Month, and so today I want to talk about how Online Reviews impact search rankings.

According to the 2021 Local Search Ranking Factors report done by Whitespark, online reviews were the #2 most important factor in local search rankings.

Note that when we talk about “local search rankings” we’re talking about results Google shows in the “local 3 pack” as shown below.  (Often there are ads and organic (aka general) results shown above and below the local 3 pack, but we’re just going to focus on the local results here.)

website design Trinity, Florida

A lot of local organizations, especially churches and nonprofits, balk at the idea of getting online reviews…

Is someone really going to visit my church or check out my nonprofit just because a bunch of people they’ve never met gave it high ratings and said nice things about us in a review?

Yes, actually they will.  90% of people say online reviews factor into their decision making.

But people won’t even have a chance to make a decision about your organization, if they can’t find it. And if you’ve got few or no online reviews, your search rankings will be lower, making it less likely people will find you when doing an online search.

Don’t Take My Word For It, Try This…

If you are a part of a local organization – a church, school, local nonprofit, or local business – go to Google and search for “[your type of organization] in [your city] [your state].”   For example, “church in Clearwater, Florida” or “accountant in Ames, Iowa” or “preschool in Hoboken, New Jersey.”

Calculate the average number of reviews the 3 organizations in the “local 3 pack” have.

Then click the “More Places” link at the bottom of the local 3 pack.  That will take you to Google Maps showing you the top 20 local results.  Scroll down to the bottom, and calculate the average number of listings of the bottom 3 (these are the organizations that rank 18-20).

Do you see a dramatic difference?

Every Organization Can Get More Online Reviews

If your organization is in the local 3 pack, that’s awesome! Congratulations! If not, you’re probably thinking, “It’s not fair, the organizations that have all those reviews are way bigger than we are!

That may be true, but look again at the organization that made the local 3 pack with the lowest number of reviews.  I guarantee your church, school, ministry or business serves more people than that.  You can get more online reviews than they have.

You just have to ask. And know how to ask.

We’ll talk more about how to do that in a future post.

For now, remember…

Online reviews are the second biggest factor in local search rankings. –Local SEO Guide

Click to share this image on Facebook, TwitterPinterest or Instagram

By the way, if you were wondering what the #1 & #3 factors in local search results is, they are a well-optimized Google Business Profile and  good organic (or general) search results.

If you’d like some help with your organic or local SEO, one of our experts at OCC would love to talk with you. Just complete the form below to schedule a call.


  • When you did the little experiment, what did you search, what were the average number of reviews in the local 3 package, and the average number of reviews for 18-20?
  • What other questions do you have online reviews and local SEO?

    Request a Free Web Design or SEO Consultation!

    I am interested in talking with someone about:
    Custom WebsiteSEOBoth
    : :
    : :

    By submitting this form, I give OurChurch.Com permission to send me communication by email.

    Share and Enjoy !

    0 0

    About the author

    Paul Steinbrueck

    Paul Steinbrueck is co-founder and CEO of OurChurch.Com, husband, father of 3, blogger. You can follow him on Twitter at @PaulSteinbrueck.